The Tallahassee City Commission voted unanimously on Wednesday to initiate the process of withdrawing from the federal 287(g) program. This controversial program allows trained local law enforcement officers to perform immigration enforcement duties under the supervision of the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The decision sets the stage for a potential showdown with Florida's state government.
According to Fox49tv, the 5-0 vote does not immediately terminate the agreement; instead, it directs city staff to draft a withdrawal plan outlining legal and financial implications for future commission consideration.
This outcome reflects the shifting political landscape within the commission. Newly elected Mayor Jeremy Matlow and Commissioner PJ Perez joined forces with Commissioner Jack Porter, forming a majority that overturned the previous commission's 3-2 decision to maintain the agreement with ICE.
The decision underscores the growing tension between local governments and federal immigration control policies. Stay updated with all developments in our U.S. Immigration section.
Porter was upfront in the debate, stating, "I'm ready to move towards exiting the 287(g) agreement."
A pivotal moment in the session occurred when Commissioner Curtis Richardson pressed Police Chief Lawrence Revell for details on the department's actual involvement in the program. Revell revealed that only one officer had been trained under the agreement, with access to the federal immigration enforcement database, highlighting the discrepancy between the city's formal participation and its operational impact.
Mayor Matlow questioned the necessity of the agreement, arguing, "State law did not require us to enter into 287(g)," and noted that participating in federal immigration control imposes a financial burden on the municipality amid potential revenue cuts.
However, the biggest hurdle lies within Tallahassee itself, the state capital and home to Governor Ron DeSantis' administration. Commissioner Diane Williams-Cox demanded clarity on the legal and financial ramifications of withdrawing. The city attorney confirmed that the commission has the authority to order an exit, though broader legal implications remain unresolved.
A clear precedent is Key West: in June 2025, it voted 6-1 to terminate its own 287(g) agreement, only to reverse the decision weeks later due to threats of sanctions, dismissals, and lawsuits from state authorities. This precedent loomed large over Wednesday’s discussions, with commissioners explicitly acknowledging the risk of retaliation.
Tallahassee's move follows a day after Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier warned Doral that canceling an existing 287(g) agreement would likely violate state laws against sanctuary cities, outlined in Chapter 908 of the Florida Statutes. These laws impose fines up to $5,000 on officials who breach its provisions and allow the governor to initiate suspension proceedings.
Tallahassee thus becomes the second city in Florida to take such action within days. Doral postponed its own agreement debate for the second time on Wednesday, awaiting a meeting between its mayor and Uthmeier scheduled for early December.
For Cuban immigrants with I-220A, Venezuelans with parole, or others with pending processes in Tallahassee, exiting the program alone would not alter their immigration status. ICE retains full federal authority to operate in the city regardless of any local agreement.
Governor-elect Byron Donalds reacted to the vote with a stern warning: "Florida is not a sanctuary state," he declared, emphasizing that Mayor Matlow has a constitutional obligation to uphold both federal and state laws.
Understanding Tallahassee's Decision on ICE Agreement
What is the 287(g) program?
The 287(g) program is a federal initiative that allows trained local law enforcement officers to perform immigration enforcement duties under the supervision of ICE.
Why is Tallahassee withdrawing from the 287(g) program?
Tallahassee is withdrawing due to concerns over financial burdens and the belief that state law does not mandate participation in the program. The decision reflects a shift in the political dynamics within the city commission.
How might this decision affect immigrants in Tallahassee?
The decision to exit the program on its own does not change the immigration status of individuals in Tallahassee, as ICE retains full federal authority to operate independently of local agreements.