CubaHeadlines

Hialeah and Doral Left Without State Senator: ACLU Urges Supreme Court to Mandate Special Election

Wednesday, November 18, 2026 by Amelia Soto

Hialeah and Doral Left Without State Senator: ACLU Urges Supreme Court to Mandate Special Election
Ron DeSantis - Image by © Flickr / Gage Skidmore

The Florida chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed a request with the state’s Supreme Court this Tuesday, aiming to compel Governor Ron DeSantis to arrange a special election for a Senate seat vacated by Cuban American Bryan Ávila nearly three months ago.

This legal action, representing Doral resident Alejandro Peñuela, highlights that the seat has remained unfilled for 84 days, marking the longest delay recorded in Florida's history for such matters.

Ávila stepped down on August 25 to join Republican Byron Donalds as a lieutenant governor candidate. Donalds subsequently won the gubernatorial election on November 3, and both are set to assume office on January 5, 2027.

The 39th Senatorial District, encompassing Hialeah, Doral, Miami Lakes, Sweetwater, and Medley, is home to nearly half a million residents, predominantly Hispanic, with a significant Cuban American presence. Hialeah, the district's epicenter, boasts over 166,000 Cuban-origin residents, making up 73.6% of its population.

This community now faces the 2027 legislative session—commencing on March 2—without a senator in Tallahassee to advocate for them, just as critical issues such as Property Tax Amendment 3, the housing insurance crisis, and residential affordability are on the agenda.

The ACLU's petition is clear: "The governor's inaction, unprecedented in its duration compared to any of his predecessors, leaves 500,000 district residents without representation, depriving them of a Capitol voice."

Florida law mandates the governor to set dates for primary and general elections when a legislative seat is vacated, though it doesn’t specify a timeframe. The ACLU notes that from 1999 to 2020, governors typically called special elections within an average of 7.6 days, with over 25 instances occurring in less than five days.

DeSantis, however, has deviated from this pattern. The organization describes this as the tenth instance where voters have had to go to court to prompt an election call: "It's a troubling pattern that undermines our republican form of government and wastes judicial resources," the petition argues.

While the seat remains unoccupied, two Republican state representatives from Hialeah are already campaigning for it: 37-year-old attorney David Borrero and 58-year-old former educator Alex Rizo, both Cuban Americans re-elected unopposed in 2026. Rizo enjoys the backing of DeSantis himself, along with Congress members Mario Díaz-Balart and Carlos Giménez.

The district is a Republican stronghold: Ávila, a Hialeah-born son of Cuban exiles, secured it in 2024 with 70% of the vote against a Democratic contender.

The ACLU urged the Supreme Court to expedite the case review before November 30, when legislative committee weeks start, leading up to the 2027 session. As of this report, Governor DeSantis's office had yet to issue a public response.

Key Questions About the Senate Vacancy in Florida

Why is the Senate seat for Hialeah and Doral still vacant?

The seat has been vacant since Bryan Ávila resigned on August 25 to run for lieutenant governor. Governor DeSantis has not yet called for a special election to fill the vacancy.

What is the ACLU's role in this situation?

The ACLU has filed a petition with the Florida Supreme Court to compel Governor DeSantis to organize a special election to fill the empty Senate seat.

Who are the potential candidates for the vacant Senate seat?

Republican state representatives David Borrero and Alex Rizo, both from Hialeah, are campaigning for the vacant Senate position.

© CubaHeadlines 2026