A video shared on Instagram this past Friday by Amanda Sanz and her partner Celle ignited a storm of controversy online. The clip featured an informal proposal filmed inside a car, accompanied by the caption: "A 'yes, I do' without all the theatrics."
Racking up over 9,280 likes and 179 comments within hours, the video surfaced a few weeks after the couple officially announced their engagement on July 9. Celle had written "She said Yes" on his hand as he displayed the engagement ring.
The uproar began with a sharp remark from a user who criticized the couple harshly: "Don't normalize these kinds of proposals wtf, calling it 'theatrics' when a man makes an effort to make that moment special, which only happens once throughout the relationship. Kneeling to honor you and ask you to be his life partner isn't theatrics; romanticizing moments with the one you love is living. Women like you create men like him," she commented.
The critique also included a direct jab at Amanda: "You don't have to belittle wonderful proposals made to women with valuable feminine energy just because it wasn't done for you."
Several male users echoed the sentiment: "Such a real and wise comment. I'm a man, and I can confirm."
Both Celle and Amanda responded directly to the criticism. Celle chose sarcasm, saying: "It's content, but let me tell you, those are the classics who divorce within three days."
Amanda tried to defuse the tension: "Very nice, but everyone should do what makes them happy. This video is content!! But still, read other comments and you'll see everyone has their own opinion. Kisses, queen."
Not all reactions were negative. One user defended the couple's stance: "The true act of love begins afterward. The romantic proposal, as you say, lasts a moment. The real marriage, a lifetime."
Another user chimed in, suggesting that an informal proposal "is often more genuine, coming from something already discussed, where your partner knows you'll say yes because you're both on the same page, in sync, and 100 percent sure you love each other."
Amanda and Celle's relationship became public in May 2025 when she confirmed it, and since then, they have maintained an active presence on social media, including musical collaborations like "Te quiero de lejos," released in September 2025.
The debate sparked by the video highlights a broader tension concerning romantic expectations in the age of social media, where the line between real life and content created for platforms is increasingly blurred.
Exploring the Social Media Proposal Controversy
Why did Amanda and Celle's proposal video cause controversy?
The video sparked controversy because some users felt that their informal proposal diminished the traditional effort and romanticism associated with such a significant moment, leading to debates on social media.
How did Celle and Amanda respond to the criticism?
Celle responded with sarcasm, while Amanda attempted to calm the situation by emphasizing personal happiness and the diversity of opinions.
What broader issue does the debate over the proposal highlight?
The debate reflects a larger issue regarding romantic expectations in the social media era, where the distinction between real life and curated content for online platforms is becoming increasingly unclear.