Florida's Attorney General, James Uthmeier, has issued a legal opinion cautioning Doral officials that terminating a current immigration cooperation agreement with ICE without adequate justification could likely breach the state's legislation against so-called sanctuary cities. This complicates efforts to end the agreement that Miami-Dade County's Doral police have with ICE.
The response was sent Wednesday to Mayor Christi Fraga, with Deputy Attorney General Greg Slemp signing the document, as reported by Florida's Voice on Thursday.
The opinion addresses two main questions: whether municipalities are required to enter into agreements under the federal 287(g) program and if they can withdraw from existing agreements.
Legal Distinctions and Implications
Slemp's conclusion draws a significant distinction between the two scenarios. While refusing to sign a 287(g) agreement does not inherently violate Florida laws, it may indicate illegal sanctuary policy depending on the context.
However, when a city has already signed such an agreement, rescinding it without sufficient justification could suggest, according to the Attorney General's Office, that the local government is hindering immigration cooperation and not making the best efforts to support federal authorities.
This interpretation relies on two provisions in Chapter 908 of Florida's laws. Article 908.103 bans sanctuary policies, while Article 908.104 requires state and local law enforcement agencies to make their best efforts to support the enforcement of federal immigration laws.
Challenges for Doral's Community
The opinion poses a significant hurdle for Doral's residents, businesses, and activists who have been advocating for months to end the agreement, particularly in a city with a large Venezuelan and Cuban community.
The expected response for Doral came just a day after the Doral City Council delayed once again its debate on collaborating with ICE, with a four-to-one vote.
The postponement was conditioned by Vice Mayor Rafael Pineyro on receiving the legal opinion requested by Mayor Fraga. Councilwoman Maureen Porras, pushing for the review or cancellation of the agreement, was the sole dissenting vote.
Impact on Cuban and Venezuelan Residents
For immigrant families in Doral, Uthmeier's response diminishes local authorities' chances of canceling the agreement without clashing with the state government.
However, this does not imply that immigration rules changed overnight or that local police have automatically gained new powers. In fact, Doral acknowledges that none of its officers have received the necessary training to operate under the 287(g) program, despite the city approving its participation in April 2025 and formalizing the agreement in January 2026.
The 287(g) program allows specific local officers, once trained and federally authorized, to perform particular immigration enforcement duties under ICE's supervision.
For Cubans with I-220A documents, Venezuelans with parole status, and other immigrants with pending processes, the legal opinion does not alter their individual immigration circumstances.
Statewide Legal Tensions
Attorney General Uthmeier also used Thursday's opinion to warn Tallahassee, where city commissioners unanimously voted on Wednesday to explore the process of ending their own 287(g) agreement.
The Tallahassee vote did not terminate the agreement but allowed the issue to be included in a future meeting to assess both the exit procedure and its potential legal consequences.
In a message posted on social media, Uthmeier reminded that withdrawing from a 287(g) agreement could demonstrate the existence of prohibited sanctuary policies and insufficient efforts to support federal immigration law enforcement.
Tallahassee Mayor Jeremy Matlow has challenged this interpretation, stating that the state law did not explicitly require his city to enter into the agreement. Commissioner Dianne Williams-Cox warned of potential sanctions if they choose to cancel it.
Precedents in Other Florida Cities
State pressure on cities attempting to withdraw from the 287(g) program has already led to decision reversals in other Florida municipalities.
In March 2025, Fort Myers' City Council initially rejected an agreement with ICE but reversed its decision and approved it unanimously after warnings from Uthmeier about possible sanctions, including the removal of officials.
Similarly, in June 2025, Key West commissioners voted to terminate police collaboration with ICE but changed their stance following threats of legal consequences and dismissals from state authorities.
Understanding Florida's 287(g) Program and Its Implications
What is the 287(g) program?
The 287(g) program allows designated local law enforcement officers, after receiving specific training and federal authorization, to perform immigration enforcement duties under the supervision of ICE.
Why is Doral's agreement with ICE controversial?
Doral's agreement with ICE is controversial due to concerns about its impact on immigrant communities, particularly those from Venezuela and Cuba, and the potential legal and economic implications for the city.
What are the potential consequences of canceling a 287(g) agreement?
Canceling a 287(g) agreement without sufficient justification could lead to legal challenges and accusations of violating state laws against sanctuary policies. It may also result in political and economic repercussions for the municipality.