On Monday in Madrid, Pablo Bustinduy, campaign spokesperson for the Frente Amplio and Minister of Social Rights under Pedro Sánchez's government, unveiled the leftist coalition's electoral program for the upcoming general elections on November 29. At the center of the debate is their controversial proposal: capping inheritances from large estates at a maximum of 10 million euros per heir.
This policy would be enacted through a 100% marginal tax rate on the portion of the Inheritance and Gift Tax exceeding that amount. Essentially, this would prevent anyone from receiving more than what the coalition deems spendable within a lifetime.
Challenging the Meritocracy Narrative
"No one in Spain will inherit more than they can spend in a lifetime. Beyond ten million euros, the money will contribute to public services, which belong to everyone else," Bustinduy stated during the program's presentation.
He further criticized the right-wing's meritocracy narrative, questioning, "What merit is there in being born into a wealthy family? What surname is worth ten million euros?"
Progressive Tax Structure
The proposed tax scale is progressive: a 75% rate for inheritances between five and 10 million euros, and 50% for those between 800,000 and five million. Meanwhile, the coalition suggests lowering tax rates for inheritances under 120,000 euros to ease the fiscal burden on the working class.
The program also dictates that lifetime donations will count towards the inheritance limit, and regional tax exemptions, like those in Madrid, where the tax is nearly abolished, will not be permitted.
Redistributive Measures and Economic Impact
Bustinduy addressed comments from Madrid's president, Isabel Díaz Ayuso, regarding the "risk" against the "dullness of social rights": "The wealthy will have to take a bit more risk in this country. After all, being born rich, the child of rich parents, and becoming a rich parent yourself is quite dull."
According to the coalition's data, there are 33 individuals in Spain with over 1 billion euros, 900 with assets exceeding 30 million, and about 10,000 with more than six million. This represents 0.002% of the population, with wealth sixty times that of a middle-class family.
The Frente Amplio estimates that these measures could double current spending on social housing policies and educational scholarships.
Additional Economic Proposals
Ada Colau, candidate for Prime Minister, previewed the proposal in a television interview, saying, "Simply because you're born into a family, your life is set for good, while others must work hard from a young age just to make ends meet."
The inheritance cap is part of a broader redistributive package that includes a 2% tax on assets over 1 million euros, increasing to 3% for those exceeding 50 million. It also proposes the progressive expropriation of housing from large investment funds and a 10% tax on real estate accumulation.
The program further advocates reducing the workweek to 32 hours progressively, lowering the retirement age to 65, and introducing a Universal Child Benefit of 200 euros per month per child, a measure also adopted by the PSOE in their platform. Bustinduy humorously remarked, "When the left crafts an electoral program, we bear the dual responsibility of shaping the left's agenda for this term and the PSOE's for the next."
These elections were called early by Sánchez following the parliamentary rejection of his housing decrees, with the PP, Vox, and Junts opposing them.
Economist Gonzalo Bernardos has warned, as reported by the Spanish press, that such measures might lead to the exodus of significant wealth abroad, potentially resulting in zero revenue for the state.
Implications of the Proposed Inheritance Limit in Spain
How would the inheritance cap affect wealthy families?
The inheritance cap would limit the amount any individual can inherit to 10 million euros, with excess amounts contributing to public services, potentially reducing the wealth retained within wealthy families.
What are the potential economic impacts of this policy?
While the policy aims to enhance social spending, critics argue it could drive wealthy individuals to move their assets abroad, potentially leading to a loss in tax revenue.
What other redistributive measures are included in the program?
The program includes a wealth tax, progressive expropriation of real estate from large funds, a reduced workweek, and a Universal Child Benefit, among other initiatives.