CubaHeadlines

Beyond Trump's Disillusionment: The Real Struggle for Cuban Self-Determination

Wednesday, November 18, 2026 by Joseph Morales

Beyond Trump's Disillusionment: The Real Struggle for Cuban Self-Determination
Donald Trump (reference image) - Image by © whitehouse.gov

The perceived "disillusionment" of Cubans with Donald Trump and Marco Rubio might offer an appealing narrative to explain the political fatigue surrounding the U.S. administration. However, this perspective falls short in capturing the full scope of Cuba's national plight.

The hopes pinned on Washington were not necessarily born from admiration for Trump but rather from the frustration of a society that has been unable to freely determine its political fate for decades.

In a recent interview with WSLR, American scholar Theodore Henken remarked that the "Trump-Rubio brand" has lost its luster among Cubans who anticipated decisive action against the dictatorship. According to Henken, the passage of time, the worsening crisis, and the Republican defeat in the November 3rd legislative elections have dampened expectations for change.

His insights stem from conversations with individuals both inside and outside of Cuba, not from any comprehensive survey. The more intriguing issue is not statistical but political: How meaningful is it to interpret Cubans' democratic aspirations through the lens of popularity, party allegiance, and dissatisfaction that typifies American politics?

A Cuban might reject Trump's crude remarks, his fondness for certain authoritarian leaders, his transactional approach to international relations, and much of his political agenda while still hoping his administration might help end Havana's dictatorship.

There is no inherent contradiction. "Trumpism" as a political identity is distinct from the hope that a foreign power could aid in unlocking a situation that citizens lack the institutional means to change.

Confusing these two concepts reduces a historical yearning for freedom to a mere fleeting preference for a U.S. president.

The Deeper Disillusionment: A History Before Trump

Cuba's true disenchantment is rooted far deeper than unmet promises from Washington. It lies in the imposition of a single-party system, the eradication of political competition, suppression of dissent, state monopoly over institutions, and the transformation of a revolution that once promised emancipation into a system that has constitutionally cemented socialism's continuity and the Communist Party's supremacy.

For nearly seven decades, Cubans have lived without the ability to peacefully replace their leaders through free and competitive elections. Protests have been quashed, opposition persecuted, and many citizens have found emigration to be their only individual escape from a collective crisis.

The expectations placed on Trump and Rubio should also be seen in this historical context. Even the willingness among some Cubans to consider foreign intervention, despite its significant human and political risks, underscores how impossible it seems to transform the country from within its own institutions.

This doesn't imply that all Cubans desire military intervention, nor that those hoping for U.S. action share the same goals or are willing to make identical sacrifices.

Instead, it highlights a more profound dilemma facing Cuban society: how to reclaim popular sovereignty that the political system itself prevents from being exercised.

U.S. Elections and Cuba's Unchanged Landscape

Henken also links the fading expectations to the Republican loss in the midterm elections, which enabled Democrats to control both chambers of Congress by January 2027. However, this shift in power dynamics doesn't automatically dismantle Trump's foreign strategy.

Congress possesses tools to oversee the Executive, influence budgets, block legislative initiatives, and set limits on military operations. Yet, the president still holds substantial authority to administer sanctions, conduct diplomatic negotiations, and make specific national security decisions.

In fact, just two days post-election, Rubio announced new sanctions targeting entities and individuals connected to the Cuban regime, a clear indicator of continued pressure.

The Republican defeat alters Washington's political landscape and could raise the costs of military intervention, particularly after the strain of the Iran conflict. But it doesn't mean Trump has abandoned his goals regarding Cuba.

Nor does it ensure these goals will be achieved promptly, or even in the medium term. The capacity to act and the possibility of inciting a democratic transition are different matters, as evidenced by Venezuela's complex situation.

Reducing this strategic uncertainty to the image of a "wrong horse," as Henken suggests regarding some Cuban-Americans' expectations, introduces an electoral interpretation that fails to explain the full scope of Cuba's pandemonium.

Are States Motivated by Altruism?

Another aspect of Henken's interview warrants critical examination. He warns of Trump's potential aim to turn Cuba into an economic gain source, subordinating democratic promises to material interests.

The risk of intervention driven by resource exploitation, without guarantees for Cuban sovereignty and rights, is a legitimate concern. However, economic interests in U.S. foreign policy aren't inherently unsettling revelations.

States are not philanthropic entities. Their international decisions cater to interests in security, power, influence, and prosperity, though they may also incorporate democratic principles and humanitarian considerations.

The Obama administration explicitly acknowledged in its October 2016 presidential directive on normalizing relations with Cuba that diplomatic and commercial engagement aimed to advance U.S. national interests.

Obama favored openness, while Trump opted for pressure. Their methods and political beliefs differ significantly, yet neither acted outside of U.S. interests.

The pertinent question isn't whether Washington seeks advantages from a potential Cuban transformation, but whether these advantages would align with a democratic transition, respect for citizens' rights, and national sovereignty.

Above all, who would be empowered to negotiate the terms of this relationship on behalf of the Cuban people?

The Paradox of Cuban Sovereignty

For decades, the regime has framed its conflict with the United States as a defense of national independence. However, this sovereignty, frequently invoked against the external enemy, doesn't translate into effective political sovereignty for the citizens.

The population, officially declared the masters of their destiny, lacks mechanisms to challenge the Communist Party's monopoly, choose between alternative political projects, or hold their leaders accountable through competitive elections.

This is a fundamental contradiction of Castrism: turning national sovereignty into an exclusive attribute of the state and its leaders while depriving citizens of exercising it against power.

Henken is correct in noting that Cuban leaders have honed their ability to withstand U.S. pressures and wait for political changes in Washington. But this resilience has an institutional explanation that deserves more attention: Cuban rulers can wait for Trump to lose an election because they themselves are not required to subject their hold on power to free elections.

The dictatorship's endurance doesn't necessarily demonstrate strength, legitimacy, or popular support. It may instead reveal the effectiveness of a system designed to prevent social discontent from translating into political change.

The potential fall of the regime shouldn't be mistaken for the automatic recovery of Cuban sovereignty. A transition driven by foreign interests, without effective citizen participation, could merely replace one form of dependency with another.

The real national issue isn't for Trump to determine Cuba's future but for Cubans to regain their right to decide it.

While in the United States, an electoral defeat can alter Congress's composition and influence presidential power, in Cuba, citizens still lack an equivalent mechanism to change their rulers.

Trump may gain or lose support, shift his priorities, or leave the White House. Yet Cubans remain trapped in a system that denies them the chance to decide, through voting, whether their leaders should stay in power.

This is the crisis that no transient measure of "disillusionment" with Washington can fully explain.

Understanding the Cuban Political Struggle

What is the primary issue facing Cuban society?

The main issue is the lack of political sovereignty for citizens, who are unable to freely choose or change their leaders through democratic means.

How does the U.S. political shift impact Cuba?

While changes in U.S. political power dynamics can influence foreign policy, they do not automatically change the situation in Cuba, where the political system remains resistant to democratic transitions.

Why do some Cubans hope for U.S. intervention?

Some Cubans see potential U.S. intervention as a means to break the political deadlock that they cannot resolve internally due to the lack of institutional mechanisms for change.

What does Henken suggest about Cuba's interaction with U.S. policy?

Henken suggests that Cuba's leadership is adept at resisting U.S. pressures and adapting to changes in U.S. politics, highlighting the regime's institutional resilience.

© CubaHeadlines 2026