The Cuban government has embarked on a significant transformation of the national economy. Five months after initiating a sweeping set of 176 economic measures, they are now asking citizens for their input. However, this gesture of public participation raises a critical question: who gave the regime the democratic authority to alter the country's economic and social fabric?
Approved in June, these reforms mark a departure from the longstanding model advocated by the Communist Party. Key changes include the introduction of private banking, expanded business ownership, private capital entry into state enterprises, an increased market role, and a shift from universal subsidies to targeted aid.
While these decisions impact the income, assets, employment, and living conditions of millions of Cubans, they were not the result of electoral competition or public debate with actual decision-making power.
Public Input After the Fact
In November, the government launched the platform "Soberanía" for public commentary on a program already well underway. By November 10, 172 of the 176 measures had their policies and procedures approved, with 231 legal norms drafted, and 131 published in the Official Gazette.
The government is open to discussing decisions already made but does not offer citizens the chance to elect a government that might propose different policies.
Economic Shift Without Political Change
Experts acknowledge the profound economic shift, arguing that reforms are necessary. In a Columbia University publication, economist Fidel Vascos González notes a paradigm shift from the economic principles previously upheld by the Communist Party.
These changes usher in an economy where the market, private ownership, and individual initiative play a larger role than in the centralized model. Despite precursors in the Party's 2021-2026 Guidelines, the scope of these measures surpasses previous restrictions.
The irony is clear: the Party that once limited private enterprise now holds the exclusive power to lift those limits, without subjecting this change to democratic competition.
Representation vs. Consultation
In representative democracies, governments don't need elections for every economic policy shift. They can act in response to unforeseen circumstances, provided citizens had a choice between political proposals and can withdraw support in future elections.
In Cuba, such political competition is absent. The 2019 Constitution's Article 5 designates the Communist Party as the supreme political force. The March 2023 parliamentary elections featured 470 candidates for 470 seats, with no competing party programs.
This system prevents citizens from voting for alternative economic projects or entrusting their implementation to a different political force. The Constitution asserts that sovereignty resides in the people, but the political system reserves leadership to a single organization, excluding governmental alternation.
Decision-Making and Accountability
The issue is not just whether the 176 measures are right or wrong. Some may boost productivity, attract investment, and broaden opportunities. Others might create inequalities or increase household costs.
The real question is who decides on these alternatives, who bears the consequences, and who is accountable. The Communist Party, which once championed centralized planning, now promotes market and private capital presence while controlling the institutions approving, implementing, and evaluating reforms.
The transfer of state assets to private entities raises questions about acquisition conditions, transparency, and oversight. Vascos González warns that economic reforms should be paired with political changes that enhance citizen control, parliamentary autonomy, and accountability. Introducing candidate competition is suggested, albeit within a democratic socialism framework.
This concern is critical as unchecked market openings can lead to wealth concentration among those with existing political influence. In Cuba, the institutions meant to oversee the Executive are part of the system led by the same party setting economic policies.
After decades of economic hardship and unmet promises of prosperity, Cubans face a new transformation with uncertain outcomes. They must endure its effects without political mechanisms to hold leaders accountable through elections.
The regime asks for opinions on reforms but not on whether citizens wish to continue under the current leadership. Popular sovereignty is more than allowing citizens to comment on power; it requires the ability to choose who wields it.
Understanding Cuba's Economic Reforms
What are the main changes in Cuba's economic reforms?
The reforms include private banking, expanded business ownership, private capital entry into state enterprises, a larger market role, and a shift from universal subsidies to targeted aids.
Why is the Cuban government seeking public input now?
The government is asking for public opinions on the economic measures despite having already advanced their legal framework, raising questions about the democratic mandate for these changes.
How does the current political system in Cuba affect economic decision-making?
Cuba's single-party system means citizens can't vote for alternative economic policies or leaders, concentrating decision-making power within the Communist Party.