A Cuban living in Santa Catarina, Brazil, has stirred up a heated conversation on social media after posting a video claiming that the southern part of Brazil is "far better than Miami." This direct comparison between two distinct migratory realities has sparked a wide range of reactions, both supportive and critical.
In a video shared on TikTok by user @yoelglezponce, the Cuban begins with a bold statement: "I'm going to give you the reasons why, for me, southern Brazil is currently much better than Miami." Throughout the video, he argues that while the United States offers higher wages, many people end up spending most of their income on rent. In contrast, he claims that in Brazil, one can live comfortably with just a single job. "Here, with a normal job, you can survive and live well," he stated.
He also critiques the social environment in Miami, pointing out that many Cubans residing there engage in gossip and controversy. He specifically mentions an obsession with public figures in the entertainment industry and criticizes what he sees as "immigration officer" attitudes among some migrants. "They come to the United States and think they are more national than the Americans themselves," he commented.
Regarding quality of life, he praises the Brazilian lifestyle, highlighting the geographic diversity, beaches, mild climate, and the friendly nature of Brazilians. "You pass by someone, and they say good morning. They care about you, ask how Cuba is," he explained, contrasting it with his experiences in the United States.
The video has attracted dozens of comments, with opinions sharply divided. Some have questioned his experience, accusing him of exaggeration or downplaying real issues within the Brazilian context. Others have agreed with his assessment, sharing positive experiences from Brazil. Frequent topics in the responses include living costs, regional violence, and migration challenges.
This post adds to other testimonies from Cuban migrants sharing their assessments of life in Brazil compared to places like the United States or Europe. One individual noted that while Brazil is not the United States or Europe, it has provided genuine opportunities to start from scratch.
A young migrant showcased how she and her partner are building their home brick by brick, defending their decision to emigrate as a way to transform their lives through hard work. Another Cuban argued that comparing Brazil to the United States is unfair because each migratory experience is unique, and success depends on individual effort.
In a similar reflection, another Cuban insisted that Brazil is far from being a country without opportunities and questioned the stigmas it sometimes faces from outsiders. These diverse perspectives illustrate a shared reality: the Cuban migration process is complex, offering no single formula or guaranteed results for everyone. Yet, Brazil, with its challenges and opportunities, remains a favored choice for those seeking a fresh start beyond the island.
Understanding the Cuban Migration Experience in Brazil
Why did the Cuban prefer Brazil over Miami?
He believes that in Brazil, people can live comfortably with a single job, whereas in Miami, much of the income goes towards rent.
What criticisms did he have about Miami?
He criticized Miami for its social environment where many engage in gossip and controversy, and for the attitudes of some migrants who act superior to Americans.
How did people react to the video?
Responses were mixed, with some agreeing with his views and others accusing him of exaggeration or minimizing Brazil's issues.