Mexican YouTuber Luisito Comunica released a new video on Tuesday detailing his journey to Cuba, specifically focusing on the tobacco-growing region of Pinar del Río. While exploring the nuances of Cuban cigar production, one of the world's most renowned, he was taken aback by the so-called tobacco readings. This practice, which dates back to the 19th century, is intended to entertain workers in factories; a designated reader recites newspapers, books, and more aloud while women strip the leaves from the tobacco.
However, what caught Luisito's attention the most was the nature of these readings, which are screened and approved by a "committee." "This is an example," he remarked, with evident discomfort, "of the indoctrination that Cuban authorities impose on their people. Just walking through the streets and constantly seeing political propaganda featuring Fidel Castro and quotes from Che Guevara, and then, while working—particularly since most companies here are state-owned—being read more about Fidel and Che and only hearing positive news about Cuba... it’s a clear indication of how the Cuban authority has kept its population in check for decades," he stated in his video.
Although he did not voice these opinions on camera while filming in the tobacco factories, instead opting for voice-over, which leaves room for various interpretations, Luisito shared his views on Cuban indoctrination with a specific message to the youth. "I want to take this moment to tell especially the young people watching this video that you don't have to think the way you're told. You can read different literature, watch different movies, listen to different news. You don't have to think like your grandparents; develop your own well-founded perspective," the content creator emphasized.
His videos have sparked mixed reactions on social media. While some express gratitude for his portrayal of the island's reality, others criticize him for allegedly echoing narratives that align with the ruling elites in Cuba.
Understanding Cuban Indoctrination and Youth Perspectives
What are tobacco readings in Cuba?
Tobacco readings are a traditional practice in Cuban factories where a designated reader recites newspapers, books, and other materials aloud to entertain workers as they process tobacco leaves. This practice dates back to the 19th century.
Why does Luisito Comunica criticize these readings?
Luisito Comunica criticizes the readings because they are controlled by a committee that approves content, often aligning with state propaganda. He sees it as a form of indoctrination, limiting diverse perspectives and reinforcing political narratives.
How does Luisito Comunica suggest Cuban youth should respond?
Luisito encourages Cuban youth to think independently and not be swayed by dictated perspectives. He advises exploring various literature, films, and news to form a well-rounded and self-developed viewpoint.