The Hialeah Police Department has decided against reopening the criminal case involving Andy Santana, the former treasurer for Alexander Otaola's political campaign. This decision follows their assessment that there isn't enough evidence to justify new charges. The revelation was made by Univision journalist Javier Díaz through a Facebook post, where he also hinted at potential civil action initiated by the complainant.
The controversy centers around Ronaldo Luis Mosqueda Toledo, a young man who, in October 2024, accused Santana of engaging in sexual relations with him while he was still a minor. This accusation led to Santana's arrest on charges of illegal sexual activity with a minor, a serious felony that could have resulted in a prison sentence of up to 15 years. However, the charges were dropped a few months later after Mosqueda recanted, claiming his initial statement was made under threats and pressure.
The case took a new turn in March of this year when Mosqueda, now 18, approached the Hialeah Police once again to formally request the case be reopened. According to his statements to Univision, he was motivated to continue his complaint after handing over his mobile phone to authorities, alleging it contained sexual content videos used to intimidate him. "The FBI will be investigating this. The FBI will be involved due to child pornography," Mosqueda declared, also holding Santana and Otaola accountable for any harm he might face for speaking up again.
Despite Mosqueda's persistence and the submission of alleged evidence, the Hialeah Police concluded there were no solid grounds to reactivate the criminal proceedings. This response has drawn criticism from Mosqueda's supporters, who have suggested a possible lack of institutional will to thoroughly pursue the case. Joe Carrillo, a private investigator assisting Mosqueda, expressed his frustration, stating, "There are people here who are being protected."
While the criminal front seems to have closed definitively, Mosqueda is reportedly preparing a civil lawsuit against Andy Santana. The case remains a topic of public interest, especially due to the political figure connected to Santana: Alexander Otaola, a Cuban activist and influencer who announced his candidacy for Miami-Dade's mayoralty in 2024. Otaola has distanced himself from the events, stating after Santana's arrest in October, "I have no control over the private lives of my employees… Each person must face the consequences of their actions and prove their innocence." He also claimed that the incident was being exploited to tarnish his public image and discredit his political activism.
The controversy continues to simmer with ongoing legal actions, new statements, and increasing scrutiny over the case's institutional handling. Although the criminal path seems closed, civil courts and potentially federal entities like the FBI might keep the investigation active in the coming months.
FAQs on the Hialeah Police's Decision and Its Implications
Why did the Hialeah Police decide not to reopen the case against Andy Santana?
The Hialeah Police determined there wasn't sufficient evidence to support reopening the criminal case against Andy Santana.
What new developments have occurred in the case involving Andy Santana?
Ronaldo Luis Mosqueda Toledo, the complainant, has attempted to reopen the case and has reportedly provided his mobile phone, containing alleged evidence, to authorities. Additionally, a civil lawsuit may be in the works.
How has Alexander Otaola responded to the situation involving his former treasurer?
Alexander Otaola has distanced himself from the allegations, stating that he cannot control his employees' personal lives and that each individual must face their responsibilities.